Guest blog post by Bálint Bajomi
Conservation translocations – including reintroductions and population reinforcements – are widely used to protect endangered animals and plants. Thousands of programmes have been carried out and are currently under way worldwide. Examples include European bison (Bison bonasus) reintroductions and the black-footed ferret (Mustela nigripes) programme in the United States. Most projects concern mammals and birds, but translocation is increasingly used for freshwater fishes too, although their outcomes are rarely assessed with standardised frameworks.
A recently published article in the journal Nature Conservation examines one such freshwater fish programme: the effort to protect the European mudminnow in Hungary.

To improve future projects and advance the science of conservation biology, the methods and outcomes of these programmes need to be monitored and published. A widely cited 2000 review of published studies suggested that about one quarter of the projects documented in the international literature have been successful, half have had uncertain outcomes, and roughly another quarter have failed. Self-assessments by project managers are far more positive: in the 2021 IUCN case-study volume, about three quarters of 69 projects were rated successful or highly successful, so the figures depend on the method used. Published figures may overestimate the true success rate, as unsuccessful projects are less likely to be reported in English-language publications.
Juliette Birot and her colleagues have proposed a common framework for assessing conservation programmes involving animals, plants and other organisms. The framework aims to make projects easier to compare and literature reviews easier to undertake. Similar in concept to the IUCN Red List, it assigns population categories according to survival, reproduction and population development, ranging from Failed to Regulating.
It also accommodates populations that are still becoming established and cases where information is insufficient. The framework considers four aspects: whether individuals survive, whether they reproduce successfully, how widely the population is distributed, and how its numbers change over time.
What the researchers did

Hungarian conservation biologists tested the framework using data from a long-term programme to protect the European mudminnow (Umbra krameri). This fish, listed as Vulnerable on the IUCN Red List, inhabits shallow water and rarely grows beyond 10 cm. It lives among dense aquatic vegetation and produces relatively few eggs, which the females guard.
In Central Europe, the mudminnow is threatened by wetland drying caused by climate change and by the invasive Amur sleeper (Perccottus glenii). Since 2008, the Tavirózsa (Water-lily) Association for Environmental Protection and Nature Conservation and the Hungarian University of Agriculture and Life Sciences (MATE) have worked to conserve the species. They have created small refuge ponds fed by groundwater and isolated from streams and other surface waters, helping to keep invasive fish out.

By 2017, ten ponds had been established, and mudminnows rescued from seven threatened populations, together with ex situ and in situ bred offspring, had been introduced. The team monitors water quality, aquatic vegetation, macroinvertebrate fauna and fish populations. This study focused on Illés Pond IV and Pócos Pond B, which are connected, and on Illés Pond VI. The ponds have dense aquatic vegetation, a surface area of about 40 m and an average depth of 1.5 m.
The last releases took place in 2012 at Illés Pond IV and Pócos Pond B, and in 2015 at Illés Pond VI. By 2022, the populations had persisted for ten and seven years, respectively, without further releases. As the species’ expected maximum lifespan is six to seven years, fish recorded after these periods must have been born locally. The ponds’ isolation limits the entry of invasive fish, but also prevents the populations from expanding naturally.
The programme has been successful, although the framework has limitations

Both populations persisted and reproduced over several generations. Larvae and adult fish of different sizes were recorded in multiple years, demonstrating repeated reproduction and survival. Despite annual fluctuations in catches and the temporary removal of adult fish for breeding, both populations persisted. Severe drought lowered water levels in 2021 and 2022.
One population was classified as Establishing/Growing, while the other was classified as Growing under the framework proposed by Birot and her colleagues. The findings show that small, isolated, groundwater-fed ponds can provide long-term refuges for the European mudminnow. Despite the species’ relatively low egg production, populations can survive and reproduce over several generations where suitable habitats are available. Future management must also address wider threats, particularly climate-change-driven drought and unsustainable water management.
The framework proposed by Birot and her colleagues proved suitable for assessing the programme and synthesising demographic evidence. However, a comprehensive assessment may be more difficult for smaller projects with limited resources or monitoring data. Further tests across species, habitats and programmes will help establish how widely the framework can be applied. Publishing the outcomes of all programmes, including failures, will help conservationists learn and improve future efforts.
Original source:
Bajomi B, Tatár S, Tóth B, Dukay I, Nyeste K, Müller T (2026) Testing a recently proposed framework for assessing the success of conservation translocations: the European mudminnow (Umbra krameri) programme in Hungary. In: Wanzenböck J, Šmejkal M, Kalous L, Klefoth T, Geist J, Takacs P (Eds.), Biology and conservation of wetland fishes in Europe. Nature Conservation 65: 173–195. https://doi.org/10.3897/natureconservation.65.189862
This article is part of: Nature Conservation 65: Biology and conservation of wetland fishes in Europe



































































